Skip to content 
Introduction to the Best Islands in Bay of Islands
The Bay of Islands is one of those places that feels almost too perfect to be real. With over 140 subtropical islands scattered across calm, turquoise waters, it is a destination that invites you to slow down, explore, and find your own hidden corner of New Zealand’s coastline. Whether you are chasing quiet beaches, scenic viewpoints, or wildlife encounters, the best islands in Bay of Islands offer something for every kind of traveller.
When I spent time exploring the islands in Bay of Islands, what stood out most was how different each island felt. Some were completely untouched, with nothing but walking tracks and birdsong, while others had historic sites, sheltered bays, and places to swim straight off the boat. It is not just about ticking off destinations here. It is about the experience of moving between them, watching the coastline change, and discovering places that feel genuinely remote.
This guide is designed to help you navigate the top islands in Bay of Islands and decide which ones are worth your time. You will find a mix of well known highlights and quieter spots that still feel undiscovered. Whether you are visiting on a day cruise, taking a private boat, or kayaking your way around, knowing where to go makes all the difference.
For more on Bay of Islands see our following blog posts –
What Makes Bay of Islands Special for Island Exploring
There are many coastal destinations in New Zealand, but the Bay of Islands stands out because of its accessibility, diversity, and calm conditions. Unlike more rugged parts of the country, the waters here are generally sheltered, which makes island hopping far more enjoyable and accessible.
Another reason the Bay of Islands is so unique is the balance between nature and history. Many of the islands are protected reserves, meaning you get untouched landscapes, native wildlife, and walking tracks that feel genuinely wild. At the same time, places like Urupukapuka Island and Russell connect you to New Zealand’s early history and coastal culture.
What visitors can expect is variety. You might spend one morning hiking to a viewpoint overlooking endless ocean, then the afternoon swimming in a quiet bay with no one else around. That contrast is what makes finding the best islands in Bay of Islands such a rewarding experience.
Quick Guide to the Best Islands in Bay of Islands
If you are short on time, the best islands in Bay of Islands can be broken down by travel style.
Some islands are perfect for relaxed beach days, like Urupukapuka Island, which offers easy access, walking tracks, and safe swimming spots. Others, like Moturua Island, are ideal if you want something quieter with a stronger sense of history and fewer crowds.
For those chasing views and photography, islands like Motukiekie and the famous Hole in the Rock area offer dramatic coastal scenery. If you are more adventurous, smaller islands and hidden bays can be reached by kayak or private boat.
Most islands are accessible via boat tours departing from Paihia or Russell. Prices vary depending on whether you are doing a guided cruise, water taxi, or renting your own boat, but there are options for every budget.
Best Islands to Visit in Bay of Islands
Urupukapuka Island
One of the first places worth visiting is Urupukapuka Island, easily the most popular and accessible island in the Bay of Islands. It combines everything you would want in a day trip, from beaches and walking tracks to panoramic viewpoints.
What I noticed about this place was how easy it was to spend an entire day here without getting bored. You can start with a coastal walk, stop for a swim in one of the sheltered bays, and then head up to the viewpoints for incredible views across the bay.
It is best suited for travellers who want a balance of relaxation and activity. The best time to visit is early in the day before the main tour boats arrive.
Google Maps – Urupukapuka Island
Moturua Island
Another spot that stood out was Moturua Island, known for its mix of history and natural beauty. This island feels quieter than Urupukapuka, making it ideal if you are looking to escape the crowds.
What I noticed about this place was the sense of space. Even during busier periods, it still feels peaceful. There are walking tracks that take you through native bush and along the coastline, with plenty of places to stop and take it all in.
This island is perfect for those who enjoy slower travel and exploring at their own pace.
Google Maps – Morturua Islands
Motukiekie Island
If you are looking for something more dramatic, Motukiekie Island, also known as Piercy Island, is a must visit. It is home to the famous Hole in the Rock, one of the most iconic landmarks in the Bay of Islands.
What I noticed about this place was the scale of it. Seeing the rock formation from a boat as you pass through the arch is one of those moments that feels uniquely New Zealand.
This is best experienced on a boat tour rather than as a stop off island, but it is still one of the top islands in Bay of Islands for scenery.
Google Maps – Motukiekie Island
Motuarohia Island (Roberton Island)
If you are searching for one of the most photogenic spots, Motuarohia Island is hard to beat. It is best known for its twin lagoons, which create a unique natural formation.
What I noticed about this place was how calm and clear the water was. It is perfect for swimming, kayaking, or simply relaxing on the beach.
It is best suited for those who want a classic island experience with incredible scenery.
Google Maps – Motuarophia Island
Moturoa Island
Moturoa Island is often overlooked, which makes it one of the best islands in Bay of Islands if you are chasing something quieter.
What I noticed about this place was how untouched it felt. There are fewer facilities here, but that is part of the appeal. It feels more like a private escape than a tourist destination.
It is ideal for travellers who want to get away from the more popular stops.
Google Maps – Moturoa Island
Russell
While not technically an island, Russell deserves a mention because of its location and experience. It acts as a gateway to many of the islands and offers a completely different perspective on the Bay of Islands.
What I noticed about Russell was its relaxed, historic feel. It is a great place to base yourself if you want easy access to island tours while still enjoying cafes, restaurants, and accommodation.
Google Maps – Russell
Where to stay in Russell (Budget)
Russel, Bay of Islands Travel Guide
How to Choose the Right Islands for You
Choosing the best islands in Bay of Islands really comes down to how you want to experience the region.
If you are looking for something more relaxed, Urupukapuka Island is the easiest choice. It gives you a bit of everything without requiring too much planning.
On the other hand, if you prefer quieter, less crowded experiences, islands like Moturua or Moturoa are worth prioritising. They offer a more personal connection to the landscape.
If I had to choose just one, I would pick a mix rather than a single island. Start with Urupukapuka for the experience, then balance it out with a quieter island to really appreciate the contrast.
Best Time to Visit These Islands in Bay of Islands
The Bay of Islands is a year round destination, but your experience will vary depending on when you visit.
Summer brings warm temperatures and calm waters, making it ideal for swimming and boating. However, it is also the busiest time, especially on popular islands.
Spring and autumn are often the best times to visit. You still get good weather, but with fewer crowds. The light during these seasons also makes for incredible photography.
Time of day matters as well. Early mornings tend to be quieter, while afternoons are perfect for relaxed swims and slower exploration.
Tips for Visiting Islands in Bay of Islands
Planning ahead makes a big difference when visiting the best islands in Bay of Islands. Booking your transport in advance is important, especially during peak seasons.
Bring essentials like water, sunscreen, and snacks, as many islands have limited facilities. Comfortable shoes are also worth packing if you plan to explore walking tracks.
One thing I found useful was allowing flexibility in the itinerary. Some of the best moments come from staying longer in a place that feels right rather than rushing through multiple stops.
Nearby Things to Do
While island hopping is the highlight, there are plenty of other experiences nearby.
You can explore Paihia, take a dolphin watching tour, or visit the Waitangi Treaty Grounds for a deeper understanding of New Zealand’s history.
If you are planning your trip, check out our full Bay of Islands travel guide on OneLife101 for a complete itinerary and accommodation options.
Frequently Asked Questions About the Best Islands in Bay of Islands
What are the best islands in Bay of Islands?
Urupukapuka Island, Moturua Island, and Roberton Island are among the most popular and rewarding to visit.
Are the islands free to visit?
Most islands are free, but you will need to pay for transport such as ferries or tours.
What is the best way to visit the islands?
Boat tours are the easiest option, but water taxis and private boats offer more flexibility.
When is the best time to visit?
Spring and autumn offer the best balance of weather and fewer crowds.
Can you stay overnight on the islands?
Yes, some islands like Urupukapuka offer basic accommodation and camping options.
Are the islands suitable for families?
Yes, many islands have safe swimming areas and easy walking tracks.
Final Thoughts on the Best Islands in Bay of Islands
The Bay of Islands is one of those destinations that rewards curiosity. The more you explore, the more you realise how much there is to see beyond the main stops.
If I were visiting Bay of Islands again, I would slow things down even more. Spend longer on fewer islands, take the time to walk further, and allow space for those quiet moments that make the experience memorable.
The best islands in Bay of Islands are not just about the places themselves, but how you experience them.